Discussion about this post

User's avatar
lars u thomsen's avatar

Debate on imperialism

Terje Alnes' entire premise in the article 'Revolutionary Times' is wrong. We do not live in revolutionary times, but in deeply reactionary times, in what Lenin called reaction across the board.

It began with the counter-revolution in 1989 and continues to this day.

The prerequisite for revolutionary times is that the working class, in alliance with other progressives, rises up to fight against capitalism. That is what we must work towards. In Lenin's article 'Imperialism and the Split in Socialism' he writes, among other things:

"It is clear why imperialism is dying capitalism, capitalism in transition to socialism: monopoly, which grows out of capitalism, is already dying capitalism, the beginning of its transition to socialism. Imperialism's enormous socialisation of labour (what its defenders - the bourgeois economists - call "intertwining") produces the same result."

That is. that the transition to socialism is a lawful process, but it requires the revolutionary subject to be implemented; communist parties that are not trapped in the swamp of opportunism, but are clarified and capable of uniting across nations.

lars u thomsen's avatar

Debate on the epoch of imperialism!

On January 3, Terje Alnes presented his article 'Revolutionary Times' in the IMM group. In several posts I have tried to have a debate with him, but without success. The only thing he can manage to do is challenge my claim that he is defending Russia in an imperialist war. He claims that he is explaining Russia's position.

His lack of desire to debate the article is due to his inability to use class analysis in relation to the parties in the imperialist war. The crucial question is which class has power?

He completely ignores this in relation to Russia. It is no longer the working class that has power, but the oligarchs who correspond to the monopolies in the Western countries. In reality, we have been knocked back to the time before 1914, when large parts of the labour movement capitulated to imperialism. Nevertheless, it is necessary to use the experiences from 'Imperialism as the Highest Stage of Capitalism' and Lenin's fight against opportunism.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?